Blog

How Ukraine's Tax Authorities Identify Connected Sole Proprietors

Andrii Spektor
Date: 18 Nov , 10:06
33 read
​ ​

Between January and early August 2026, Ukraine's State Tax Service (STS) identified more than 500 brands and trademarks showing indicators of artificial business splitting. An analysis of 23 major retail networks identified the involvement of more than 1,000 sole proprietors, with potential budget losses preliminarily estimated at no less than UAH 1.7 billion.


In late October 2026, the issue of artificial business splitting was separately discussed at a meeting of the Interagency Working Group on the De-shadowing of the Economy. The government announced stronger cooperation among tax, customs, and law enforcement authorities concerning taxpayers classified as high-risk.

Where Is the Line Between Legitimate Cooperation and Artificial Business Splitting?

The Tax Code of Ukraine does not impose a general prohibition on several sole proprietors operating under a shared brand. Nor does the law require every entrepreneur to maintain a separate office, employ an individual accountant, or own a unique trademark. Several entrepreneurs may lawfully share infrastructure, rent premises, purchase accounting services from the same provider, or cooperate under franchise agreements.


The fundamental question is whether each of them remains an independent business operator.


Under subparagraph 14.1.36 of the Tax Code, business activity involves the production and sale of goods, performance of work, or provision of services aimed at generating income. Independence, systematic activity, and conducting business at one's own risk are also relevant to assessing an entrepreneur's operations. For example, a retail network may include several sole proprietors, each independently purchasing goods, setting prices, entering into contracts, bearing expenses, and receiving their own revenue. The existence of a common brand does not, in such circumstances, eliminate genuine commercial independence.


A different situation arises where goods are purchased by a single organizer, employees are managed by one executive, and sole proprietors are used primarily to process sales and distribute turnover among different single-tax payers. Under this model, the formal existence of separate registration numbers, bank accounts, and tax returns may not reflect the actual substance of the business operations.


​ ​

How Tax Authorities Identify Connections Between Formally Independent Entrepreneurs

Articles 71–74 of the Tax Code establish mechanisms for collecting, processing, and using tax information. Within the procedures prescribed by law, tax authorities may cross-reference tax returns, transaction records, business premises, employment information, and other data.


What matters is not so much an individual indicator as its relationship with other circumstances. A shared IP address used to submit electronic tax returns for several sole proprietors may simply reflect centralized accounting services. Similarly, using the same business address or premises does not establish that the entrepreneurs lack independence. However, when these circumstances are combined with shared employees, an absence of independent procurement, centralized control over payments, and the systematic replacement of sole proprietors as they approach the applicable income threshold, the concerns become substantially more serious.


Tax authorities may pay particular attention to data from cash registers and software-based cash registers (RRO/PRRO), information about business premises reported through Form No. 20-OPP, and documents establishing the origin of goods. Cross-referencing such information may help determine who actually makes sales, uses business assets, and receives revenue. An additional instrument is the tax risk management system, the experimental implementation of which was introduced by Cabinet of Ministers Resolution No. 854 of July 25, 2024.


However, automated analysis cannot replace inspection procedures established by law, and a tax risk indicator is not equivalent to proof of a violation. Changes introduced by Law No. 5020-IX of October 14, 2026, are also relevant. Since October 27, the law has required verification of the legal grounds for using real estate when establishing a legal entity or changing its registered location. These rules do not directly introduce new criteria for identifying business splitting, nor do they extend an equivalent address-verification procedure to the registration of sole proprietors. Nevertheless, they illustrate the growing emphasis on documentary evidence supporting a business's legal structure.

​ ​

Case Law: What Must the Tax Authority Prove?

The Supreme Court's judgment of December 12, 2025, in case No. 600/1052/20-а remains particularly relevant when assessing tax claims against retail networks. The dispute arose between the tax authority and a company associated with the Tor-Ba warehouse-store network. The tax authority alleged that the company sold goods through controlled sole proprietors and that some of these entrepreneurs effectively performed the functions of employees. Among the circumstances cited by the STS were the use of common IP addresses for filing tax returns, records of cash movements seized during searches, and materials from criminal proceedings. However, the Supreme Court upheld the lower courts' decisions cancelling the relevant tax assessment notices. The decisive issue was the insufficiency of evidence establishing specific violations. In particular, the tax authority failed to provide the court with the primary documents underlying substantial additional assessments. Moreover, the generalized list of documents in the inspection report did not allow the relevant business transactions to be properly examined.


Two further Supreme Court judgments delivered in 2026 are equally relevant to businesses.


The judgment of June 9, 2026, in case No. 380/26084/24 concerned an on-site tax inspection of an electronics store. The entrepreneur challenged a penalty exceeding UAH 1 million, arguing, among other things, that the retail premises contained goods belonging to other business entities. The Supreme Court identified a substantial violation of the procedure for authorizing the inspection: the inspection order did not properly identify the specific taxpayer. Instead of identifying the entity subject to tax control, the authorities relied on the commercial name of the retail establishment. The Court overturned the lower courts' decisions, upheld the entrepreneur's claim, and declared the tax assessment notice unlawful.


The judgment of October 13, 2026, in case No. 380/5635/25 reaffirmed this approach. In a dispute concerning penalties imposed following an on-site inspection of a retail store, the Supreme Court again emphasized the failure to properly identify the sole proprietor in the inspection order. The Court held that this defect concerned the legal basis for exercising tax control rather than merely a formal deficiency in the document. Following the cassation appeal, the relevant tax assessment notices were cancelled.

We advise you to read

View all articles

Contacts

To apply online with your question kindly send your letter to the below email.

Andrii Spektor

Andrii Spektor

Bankruptcy and Taxation Attorney

Download Contact
Phone number +380 97 656 71 35

Use your smartphone to read the QR-code, after which you can add me to your contacts.