Blog

Business Ownership Split 50/50: How to Resolve a Corporate Deadlock

Andrii Spektor
Date: 20 Nov , 9:55
42 read
​ ​

Two business partners establish a limited liability company (LLC), each acquiring 50% of its share capital. One partner is responsible for financing and business development, while the other manages the company as its director. For several years, the arrangement works well, until disagreements arise over the company's future.


Replacing the director becomes impossible because it requires a resolution of the general meeting of participants. Selling an ownership interest to the other partner is equally difficult because they cannot agree on a price. Attracting an outside investor or restructuring corporate management requires decisions that the partners are no longer capable of making jointly.

Meanwhile, the director continues to control daily operations, corporate records, banking relationships, and access to information. Formally, both partners remain equal owners, yet their actual ability to influence the company differs substantially.


In corporate law, this situation is known as a deadlock: a management impasse in which shareholders or participants cannot adopt the decisions necessary for the company to operate because of the distribution of voting rights or other corporate governance restrictions.


Ukrainian legislation does not provide a universal mechanism for forcibly resolving such conflicts. However, recent Supreme Court case law is gradually defining the boundaries of judicial intervention.

When Can a Court Intervene in Corporate Management?

Article 30 of the Law of Ukraine "On Limited and Additional Liability Companies" assigns the appointment and termination of the executive body's powers to the general meeting of participants.


Under ordinary circumstances, a court should not substitute itself for the general meeting or independently decide who should manage a company. But what happens when the statutory mechanism cannot be used precisely because of the conduct of one of the participants?


The Supreme Court's judgment of July 8, 2026, in case No. 904/2253/24 provides an important example.

​ ​

In Vostok LLC, two participants held equal ownership interests. One of them also served as director. The other repeatedly requested that a general meeting be convened to address the director's replacement but was unable to achieve any result.

Seeking to protect his rights, he brought proceedings requesting the termination of the director's powers and the appointment of a person to perform the director's duties temporarily. The lower courts dismissed the claim, referring, among other things, to the exclusive authority of the general meeting and the allegedly inappropriate remedy sought.


The Supreme Court disagreed with this formalistic approach. The Court explained that prolonged obstruction of corporate management may violate not only a participant's right to take part in the company's affairs but also effectively restrict the exercise of ownership rights over their share. Where the statutory mechanisms for replacing a director have been exhausted and another participant prevents the necessary resolution from being adopted, a claim seeking judicial termination of the director's powers may constitute an appropriate remedy. However, the Supreme Court did not itself remove the director or appoint a replacement. Instead, it set aside the lower courts' decisions and remitted the case for a new hearing because the relevant circumstances of the corporate deadlock had not been adequately examined.


This distinction is particularly important for business owners. Judicial protection may be available, but simply claiming that the partners cannot reach an agreement is insufficient. The claimant must establish an actual infringement of corporate rights, the duration of the deadlock, and the inability to resolve the conflict through the mechanisms provided by law. Relevant evidence may include written requests to convene meetings, notices sent to participants, meeting minutes, correspondence, provisions of the company's charter, and documents demonstrating the consequences of management inaction.

Shareholders' Agreements: What Partners Should Agree on in Advance

Resolving a corporate deadlock through litigation remains a complex and time-consuming process. It is far more effective to anticipate potential conflicts when establishing the joint business. Article 7 of the Law on LLC allows participants to enter into a shareholders' agreement, or corporate agreement, governing the exercise of corporate rights, the acquisition or sale of ownership interests.


​ ​

The practical importance of such arrangements is illustrated by the Supreme Court's judgment of April 13, 2026, in case No. 927/133/25. Two partners, each controlling a 50% interest in a joint agricultural business, included a provision in their corporate agreement requiring one of them to notify the other in advance of any change in the ownership structure of the company through which that partner held its interest. The notification had to be delivered at least 30 days before the relevant change. The parties agreed on compensation of UAH 20 million for a breach of this obligation.


Subsequently, one of the parties sought to invalidate the provision, arguing, among other things, that it was disadvantageous and fell outside the permissible scope of a corporate agreement. The Supreme Court upheld the dismissal of the claim. The relevant chamber of the Court found that the obligation to notify a partner of a change of control directly concerned the management of the joint business and was consistent with the principle of freedom of contract.


At the same time, the Court did not exclude the possibility of reducing excessive compensation in an appropriate dispute. The judgment does not mean that UAH 20 million was actually recovered or that every contractual penalty will necessarily be enforced in full.


For business owners, the broader lesson is that a shareholders' agreement can govern not only voting at general meetings but also the partners' conduct in circumstances that may threaten the stability of their joint business.


In companies with a 50/50 ownership structure, it is advisable to establish in advance procedures for resolving management disagreements, obtaining independent valuations of ownership interests, arranging the buyout of one partner's interest by the other, and making urgent corporate decisions.


Particular attention should be paid to exit arrangements. If a shareholders' agreement establishes a clear procedure for buying out an ownership interest following a prolonged conflict, the partners may be able to end their relationship without completely paralyzing the company's operations.


However, such mechanisms must comply with applicable law and be legally enforceable. A general commitment to negotiate or to make all decisions unanimously cannot replace a specific procedure for situations in which agreement becomes impossible.

We advise you to read

View all articles

Contacts

To apply online with your question kindly send your letter to the below email.

Andrii Spektor

Andrii Spektor

Bankruptcy and Taxation Attorney

Download Contact
Phone number +380 97 656 71 35

Use your smartphone to read the QR-code, after which you can add me to your contacts.