Blog

How to Protect Business from a Dishonest Director: Safeguards for LLC Owners

Andrii Spektor
Date: 16 Nov , 10:47
45 read
​ ​

Appointing a director does not transfer ownership of the business to that person, but it does grant broad authority to act on the company's behalf. The company itself, rather than its members personally, becomes a party to contracts entered into by its director. If a director sells equipment below market value, grants a loan to an affiliated company, or signs an unfavorable guarantee, simply removing that director from office will not undo the consequences. The contracts may remain legally binding, and recovering assets may require litigation. Business owners therefore need to address two separate objectives: preventing unilateral decisions that expose the company to serious risks and ensuring effective legal remedies if misconduct has already occurred.

Which Powers Should Be Restricted in the Company's Charter?

Under Article 39 of the Law of Ukraine on Limited and Additional Liability Companies, the executive body manages the company's day-to-day operations. Article 44, however, allows companies to establish special approval procedures for significant transactions. The law already provides that a transaction involving an asset or subject matter valued at more than 50% of the company's net assets, according to its most recently approved financial statements, requires approval by the general meeting of members unless the charter provides otherwise. However, this statutory rule alone is insufficient for comprehensive control.


First, the charter may establish a different approval procedure. Second, the value of net assets changes over time, and certain high-risk transactions may fall below the statutory threshold. The charter should therefore identify specific categories of transactions requiring prior approval from the company's members or another designated corporate body:

  • Disposal of or creation of security interests over real estate, major equipment, and other essential assets.
  • Obtaining loans or credit facilities and granting loans, sureties, pledges, or guarantees.
  • Entering into contracts above a specified monetary threshold, regardless of the company's net asset value.
  • Transferring assets without consideration and conducting related-party transactions.


For example, a manufacturing company may allow its director to independently conclude ordinary-course contracts worth up to UAH 500,000, while transactions exceeding that amount require approval from the members. The sale or mortgaging of production facilities could require approval regardless of their value.

​ ​

Why Charter Restrictions May Not Be Enough

The most difficult disputes arise when a director breaches the charter, but the counterparty insists that the contract remains valid. Article 92(3) of the Civil Code of Ukraine protects good-faith third parties. Internal restrictions on the authority of a company's representative generally have no legal effect against such parties unless the company proves that the counterparty knew, or under the circumstances could not have been unaware, of those restrictions. The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court addressed this issue in detail in its judgment of December 3, 2025, in case No. 914/768/22. The company challenged a contract on the grounds that its director had exceeded their authority. The Grand Chamber explained that a contractual statement indicating that the director acted “on the basis of the charter” did not, in itself, establish that the counterparty was aware of the restrictions contained in that charter. The Supreme Court overturned the appellate court's decision invalidating the contract and upheld the first-instance judgment. The practical lesson for business owners is clear: it is not enough to establish restrictions; the company must also be able to prove that its counterparties were aware of them. Accordingly, after amending the charter, the company should verify the information recorded in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities, Individual Entrepreneurs and Public Associations. Article 9 of Law No. 755-IV provides for the registration of information concerning restrictions on a legal entity's representation.


For important commercial relationships, contracts should be supported by a resolution of the authorized corporate body approving the relevant transaction. The delivery and receipt of these documents should be properly recorded.

How to Establish Financial and Asset Controls

Legal restrictions should be supported by practical organizational measures. Otherwise, a director may transfer company funds before the members even become aware of the misconduct. When arranging banking services, owners should examine whether the bank offers payment limits, additional authorization for substantial transfers, and segregation of signing powers. The available mechanisms depend on the bank's terms and the company's governance structure.

​ ​

The company should also ensure that authorized individuals have access to financial reporting independently of the director, establish controls over qualified electronic signatures, and regularly review transactions involving affiliated counterparties. The director's service or employment agreement should define reporting obligations, duties to disclose conflicts of interest, document handover procedures, and requirements to report material risks. Liability provisions must comply with mandatory corporate, civil, and employment law.

What Should Owners Do If the Director Has Already Acted Improperly?

Where there are indications of asset diversion or abuse of authority, owners should respond systematically.


1. Preserve the evidence. Obtain contracts, amendments, bank statements, accounting records, corporate resolutions, and correspondence. Establish when and on what basis the director carried out the transaction, identify the counterparty, and determine whether the company received the agreed consideration.


2. Prevent further high-risk transactions. Where legally justified, adopt the necessary corporate resolutions concerning the director's authority, complete the required registration procedures, update banking access rights, and secure the handover of company documents. Removing a director does not invalidate contracts already concluded.


3. Conduct a financial review. Assess the company's actual or potential losses, investigate relationships between counterparties, trace the movement of funds, and determine the location of company assets. An independent auditor may be required.


4. Select the appropriate legal remedy. Depending on the circumstances, this may involve challenging a transaction, claiming damages from the director, recovering company property, or applying for interim protective measures. Exceeding authority does not automatically render a contract invalid.


5. Monitor limitation periods. Identify when the company became, or should have become, aware of the violation and prepare the relevant claims without delay.


The final point is particularly important. In its judgment of June 14, 2023, in case No. 904/8586/21, the Commercial Cassation Court considered a claim for damages against a former director. The Supreme Court overturned those decisions, finding that the courts had failed to properly examine the arguments concerning valid reasons for the delay, and remitted the case for a new hearing.

We advise you to read

View all articles

Contacts

To apply online with your question kindly send your letter to the below email.

Andrii Spektor

Andrii Spektor

Bankruptcy and Taxation Attorney

Download Contact
Phone number +380 97 656 71 35

Use your smartphone to read the QR-code, after which you can add me to your contacts.